|Year : 2020 | Volume
| Issue : 4 | Page : 240-257
Ramadan fasting in health and disease (2019): A narrative review
Khawla F Ali1, Sara A Abdulla2, Amal Badi3, Khadija Hafidh4, Salem Arifi Beshyah5
1 Department of Medicine, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland Medical University of Bahrain, Adliya, Bahrain
2 Department of Biochemistry, Faculty of Medicine, University of Benghazi, Benghazi, Libya
3 Obstetrics and Gynecology Clinic, Medical International Specialist Center, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
4 Department of Medicine, Dubai Medical College; Department of Diabetes and Endocrinology, Rashid Hospital, DHA, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
5 Department of Medicine, Dubai Medical College, Dubai; The Endocrinology Department, Mediclinic Airport Road Hospital, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates
|Date of Submission||11-Nov-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||13-Nov-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||31-Dec-2020|
Dr. Salem Arifi Beshyah
Department of Medicine, Dubai Medical College, Dubai
United Arab Emirates
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Introduction: Literature on the health aspects of Ramadan fasting (RF) is widespread in many journals, making it less readily available to those interested in the subject. Materials and Methods: This is a narrative, nonsystematic review of international literature from two major online databases (viz., Scopus and PubMed) in 1 year (2019). The search term “RF” was used, and relevant literature was narrated in a concise thematic account excluding diabetes. Results: The publications spanned the fundamental, clinical, ethical, professional, cultural, and advocacy facets of the subject. The publications crossed the conventional disciplinary lines and geographical locations and appeared in journals with different access systems. The content is presented under relevant themes depending on the available literature. Basic coverage included changes in physiology, nutrition, and metabolism during Ramadan. Clinical aspects such as the impact of RF on kidney function, pregnancy outcome, fetal life, structure and function of eyes, and athletes' well-being received comparatively prominent coverage by researchers in 2019. Gut, liver, skin, skeleton, and blood were also covered. Other workers focused on documenting the perception, attitudes, and practices of both patients and health-care professionals during Ramadan. Conclusions: The health aspects of RF received sustained academic interest with a wide spectrum in 2019. We provided a scoping overview to help researchers and clinicians catch up quickly with the state-of-the-art today.
Keywords: Bibliometric, diabetes, literature, patients' perceptions, pregnancy, professional, Ramadan, research, sports medicine
|How to cite this article:|
Ali KF, Abdulla SA, Badi A, Hafidh K, Beshyah SA. Ramadan fasting in health and disease (2019): A narrative review. Ibnosina J Med Biomed Sci 2020;12:240-57
|How to cite this URL:|
Ali KF, Abdulla SA, Badi A, Hafidh K, Beshyah SA. Ramadan fasting in health and disease (2019): A narrative review. Ibnosina J Med Biomed Sci [serial online] 2020 [cited 2021 Jan 18];12:240-57. Available from: http://www.ijmbs.org/text.asp?2020/12/4/240/305965
| Introduction|| |
Ramadan, the 9th lunar month, is a religious month dedicated to fasting, prayer, and charity. The impact on health and disease stems from the biological impact of the fasting itself and the associated social changes. Recently, health-care providers have gained increased interest regarding the possible health-related risks as a consequence of Ramadan fasting (RF) practiced by adult Muslims in this month. It entails that they abstain from eating and drinking between the dawn and sunset.
Medical and religious scholars got closer in their approach to patients' advice based on objective risk assessment in common conditions such as diabetes. Muslim patients with acute or chronic medical conditions may be exempted from fasting; many still choose to observe the fast sometimes against medical advice. This may adversely affect their health if not appropriately addressed by evidence-based recommendations.,
Keeping up with the developments in RF research may prove difficult, and, hence, a narrative overview under a single cover may be particularly useful in presenting a digest of the research and expert opinion. We have previously reviewed the literature published in 2017 and 2018 in this journal., The aim of the present review is to provide a thematic overview of the global research work in 2019. The review aims to give a concise bird's eye view of the literature and highlight the evidence base that may direct clinical practice.
| Materials and Methods|| |
This is a narrative, nonsystematic review of the literature retrieved from two online databases over a full calendar year (2019). The search term “Ramadan fasting” was used to identify the relevant records. The PubMed and SCOPUS search retrieved 141 and 134 records, respectively. Due to their extensive number, articles on diabetes were submitted separately elsewhere and were excluded from the present manuscript to keep the size of the manuscript within reasonable limits. The selected articles were reviewed and narrated thematically to provide a reasonably concise but adequate representative. SAB drafted the initial manuscript, and all authors (a) developed further their assigned sections and (b) reviewed the whole document for intellectual content using a single version loaded online using Google Docs. Only full-text research articles in English were included. The final product was refined through several multilateral rounds of discussion. All authors contributed to the revision and finalization of the manuscript. They all approved the final version of the manuscript before submission.
| Results|| |
Physiological changes in healthy individuals
RF is thought to exert a number of physiological changes in both healthy individuals and those with medical conditions. Seven studies during 2019 addressed the impact of RF on different physiological parameters in otherwise healthy people of various ages. These included effects on muscle function and muscle mass in older people; insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1); interleukin (IL) (IL)-2; lipid profiles; risk of heat stroke in the summer; red blood cell and white blood cell parameters; serum levels of irisin, adiponectin, and leptin; verticality perception in young adults; and the anatomical, physiological, and cognitive function of healthy individuals practicing fasting during Ramadan.
Akın et al. evaluated the physiological effects of RF on muscle function and muscle mass in older people. Measurements were obtained for walking speed, muscle strength, body composition, and detailed dietary diaries. The study found no significant changes in body weight, muscle function, or muscle mass before and after RF. The authors concluded that RF supplied no risk for muscle function or muscle mass in older people. Rahbar et al. investigated the effects of fasting in Ramadan on IGF-1 and IL-2 levels in a sample of adult men. After RF, serum IGF-1 and IL-2 levels significantly decreased compared to that of before Ramadan. In addition, other favorable metabolic parameter changes were seen after Ramadan, namely, triglycerides (TGs), total cholesterol (TC), and low-density lipoprotein-cholesterol (LDL-C) levels significantly decreased, in addition to significant decreases in weight, waist circumferences (WCs), calorie, carbohydrate, and fat intake. The authors concluded that fasting in Ramadan attenuates inflammation and is beneficial to metabolic health. Alzoughool et al. examined the effect of RF on additional metabolic parameters such as serum levels of irisin, adiponectin, and leptin in healthy students. All levels significantly reduced after Ramadan, with irisin levels significantly correlating with the physical activity level of participants. Culha et al. measured circulating obestatin levels in 35 normal weight and 30 people with obesity before and after Ramadan. Obestatin levels were significantly lower in obese individuals than that in controls and obestatin and high-density lipoprotein-cholesterol (HDL-C) levels increased after Ramadan in obese group. After Ramadan, body mass index (BMI), Homeostatic Model Assessment-Insulin Resistance, fasting blood glucose, and fasting insulin correlated inversely with obestatin level. These results suggest that the changes in the pattern of sleep and fasting and eating during Ramadan may lead to increased obestatin in obese subjects, and this result may positively affect obesity, glucose, and lipid metabolism. Manjunath et al. examined the physiological effects of prolonged fasting among employees in thermally challenging conditions: an aluminum smelter. The researchers found that the average heart rate and urine-specific gravity increased in the first 4 h of shift work, while tympanic temperature did not rise significantly. The measurements stabilized in the second 4 h. The authors called for robust workplace measures for industries with high process temperatures in order to minimize the enhanced risk of heat stress and illness during Ramadan. Ahmed investigated the effects of RF on red and white blood cell parameters among female subjects. The authors found that fasting in Ramadan significantly increased red blood cell counts compared to that of pre-Ramadan. In addition, total and differential leukocytes counts decreased significantly at the end of Ramadan among female participants. Razzak et al. investigated the effect of RF on vertical perception and spatial orientation using computerized rod and frame testing. The study concluded that neither the effects of fasting status nor the time of day was significant for rod alignment errors, and that any adverse effect of RF on activities that are critically dependent on verticality perception and spatial orientation, such as sports and driving, may not be due to verticality misperception. Finally, Iqbal et al. comprehensively investigated the anatomical, physiological, and cognitive functions of healthy individuals practicing fasting during Ramadan, utilizing a variety of tests including body composition, neurocognitive analyses, memory tasks, spatial tasks, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). At the end of Ramadan, there were significant decreases in body weight, fat-free mass (FFM), and trunk-predicted muscle mass. Performance at spatial tasks improved, whereas that of memory tasks did not. Cortical thickness data on whole-brain MRI did not change significantly. The authors concluded that RF may lead to weight loss, FFM reductions, and some improvements in cognitive function in some individuals.
Nutritional changes in Ramadan
RF causes important changes in the nutritional status of those fasting. Evidence of this stems from studies that addressed nutritional balance, body composition, and energy expenditure. Nachvak et al. determined food intake, glucose homeostasis, lipid profiles, and body composition before, during, and after RF in healthy men. Statistically significant decreases were seen in food intake (except carbohydrates), BMI, body fat percentage (BFP), fasting blood sugar, and circulating TG at the end of Ramadan. In contrast, insulin resistance significantly increased at the end of Ramadan. The changes observed were transient, and returned to pre-Ramadan levels 1 month after Ramadan. Ben Jemaa et al. determined the impact of a nutritional education program before Ramadan on dietary intake, anthropometry, and body composition in an interventional study of Type 2 diabetes mellitus patients. During RF, carbohydrate intake reduced in both the study subjects and controls. Protein and saturated and monounsaturated fatty acid intake increased significantly in the group who did not receive education. The authors concluded that a nutritional education program before Ramadan can positively impact diabetes patients who fast during the holy month. Das et al. studied the food intake pattern among children, adults, and elderly persons before and after Ramadan in the eastern part of India to evaluate Ramadan fasting on body weight and BMI. All the three age groups showed an increase in body weight and BMI after 1 month of RF compared to pre-Ramadan control values. Excess intake of fat, sugar, and energy, along with a sedentary work routine, was the main factor identified as a contributor toward such an increase. The study also pointed out socioeconomic status as an important determinant of anthropometric changes. While epidemiological evidence indicates an association between higher meal frequencies and lower disease risk, experimental trials have shown conflicting results. The influence of meal frequency and timing on health and disease was examined. Furthermore, recent prospective research has demonstrated a significant increase in disease risk with a high meal frequency (≥6 meals/day) compared to a low meal frequency (1–2 meals/day). Apart from meal frequency and timing, they also have to consider the distribution of daily energy intake, caloric restriction, and night-time eating. A regular meal pattern including breakfast consumption, consuming a higher proportion of energy early in the day, reduced meal frequency (i.e., 2–3 meals/day), and regular fasting periods may provide physiological benefits such as reduced inflammation, improved circadian rhythmicity, increased autophagy and stress resistance, and modulation of the gut microbiota. Also, the gender-based differences in the metabolic response to fasting were studied in a cross-sectional study gathering data on subjects' demographics, anthropometrics and nutritional data. Biochemical parameters were also analyzed. The results demonstrated increased weight, BMI, body fat (%), and muscle mass in women, while men demonstrated decreases in weight, BMI, and body fat (%). The WC/hip circumference ratio decreased in men, but stayed the same in women. Daily water consumption increased in both women and men. Serum levels of HbA1c decreased in both genders. Serum creatinine, uric acid, albumin, TC, HDL, and LDL altered significantly in women, whereas the only significance observed in men was in serum glucose. Systolic blood pressure (SBP) and diastolic blood pressure increased in both genders. The authors concluded that RF affects the nutritional status and serum parameters in a different way for women compared to men.
Ismail et al. reviewed the similarities and differences between time-restricted feeding and RF in 25 articles (15 original and 10 reviews) published between 2000 and 2017. In spite of the heterogeneity of these studies, the authors concluded that time-restricted feeding and RF have many similar characteristics. They also reported positive health effects, including weight reduction, reduction in body fat, improvement in glucose tolerance and insulin resistance, and cardiometabolic benefits. Two review articles considered the effects of RF on energy balance., The first reviewed knowledge on different aspects of energy balance in Ramadan as a standard model to learn from and also map out strategies for healthier outcomes in such settings. RF is a state of intermittent liver glycogen depletion and repletion. The earlier (morning) part of the fasting day is marked by the dominance of carbohydrates as the primary fuel, but lipid becomes more critical toward the afternoon as the time for breaking the fast at sunset (Iftar) gets closer. The practice of observing RF is accompanied by changes in sleeping and activity patterns, as well as circadian rhythms of hormones, including cortisol, insulin, leptin, ghrelin, growth hormone, prolactin, sex hormones, and adiponectin. Few studies have investigated energy expenditure in the context of RF, including resting metabolic rate and total energy expenditure, and found no significant changes with RF. Changes in activity and sleeping patterns, however, do occur and are different from that of non-Ramadan days. Weight changes in the context of RF are variable and typically modest with inter-individual variation. Finally, a systematic review and meta-analysis of 33 studies including apparently healthy subjects examined the effects of RF on lipid parameters. The primary finding was that LDL-C levels significantly increased, whereas HDL-C and very LDL-C significantly decreased after RF. RF showed no significant effect on circulating TG, TC, and LDL-C levels. Change in TG levels was associated with age, its baseline values, and weight changes during the fasting period. The authors concluded that RF might be accompanied by a moderate improvement in lipid and lipoprotein parameters, especially HDL-C levels.
Impact of Ramadan fasting on inflammation
Several studies addressed the impact of RF on various markers of inflammatory and oxidative processes employing different designs, analytical methods, and statistical assessments.,,,,, Karsen et al. compared various indices of oxidative stress (OS) in fasting and nonfasting subjects using a novel automated colorimetric method. Total oxidant status (TOS), total antioxidant capacity levels, and OS index were analyzed. With this, they determined whether fasting had any beneficial effects on human health. The authors found the TOS level of the nonfasting group to be higher. Almeneessier et al. assessed the effect of fasting during and after Ramadan on plasma levels of IL-1β, IL-6, and IL-8, while controlling for sleep/wake pattern, sleep length and quality, meal composition, energy consumption and expenditure, and light exposure. Fasting outside of the month of Ramadan was performed to evaluate the effect of intermittent fasting (IF) in the absence of the way of life accompanying Ramadan. They demonstrated that under controlled conditions, IF led to significantly decreased plasma levels of cytokines (IL-1β, IL-6, and IL-8), particularly IL-1β and IL-6 across 24 h. IF did not affect the circadian patterns of the measured cytokines. Mushtaq et al. investigated the effect of fasting during Ramadan on plasma adiponectin and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-α) levels in a cross-sectional study comprising a total of 55 females and 55 males, aged between 20 and 40 years, who fasted during Ramadan (2014). The study found increased plasma adiponectin and decreased TNF-α levels and body weight with RF. Mrad et al. assessed the impacts of RF on some biomarkers measured in men with stable chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) fasting during Ramadan. Three sessions (before, at the end, and after Ramadan) were selected. Blood samples of OS (homocysteine and thiobarbituric acid reactive substances) and antioxidant system (AOS) (catalase, ceruloplasmin, superoxide dismutase [SOD], zinc, and albumin) biomarkers were obtained before the Iftar. Homocysteine, ceruloplasmin, SOD, thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS), catalase, zinc, and albumin were not significantly affected by RF. The number of patients with high OS or low AOS statuses was not significantly influenced by RF. In conclusion, RF did not induce any significant statistical or clinical changes in OS/AOS biomarkers or statuses in COPD patients. In order to determine whether RF is associated with an increased risk for infections, Ben Ayed et al. examined the prognostic factors of recurrent urinary tract infections (UTIs) in the setting of RF through a retrospective data review of patients diagnosed with UTI in Sfax, Tunisia (2010–2017). During the follow-up of 867 patients with UTI, recurrent UTI was a prevalent and challenging condition among patients with UTI, with both diabetes mellitus and RF seemingly increasing the recurrence in UTI.
Furthermore, a systematic review and meta-analysis examined changes in inflammatory and OS markers in healthy people after Ramadan. RF resulted in very small reductions in IL-1; C-reactive protein (CRP)/high-sensitivity CRP; and malondialdehyde, an OS marker, and small reductions in TNF-α and IL-6. The authors concluded that RF provides some protection against elevated inflammatory and OS markers, which may offer an opportunity to reduce low-grade systemic inflammation and OS and subsequent adverse health effects in healthy people.
Fasting and kidney disease
The interest in kidney function and disease during RF continued in 2019. Tashkandi et al. assessed whether lipids and lipoproteins were primarily impacted during Ramadan in chronic hemodialysis (HD) patients. In addition, the group looked at parameters such as renal function, muscle mass, and muscle strength. Throughout the study, changes in renal-related parameters were minor, as were changes in plasma lipids. Proportions of LDL and HDL did not change over the study period. The mean LDL particle diameters were higher during the Ramadan period, but the changes over the study period were small. No changes were noted concerning strength or muscle mass. Megahed et al. assessed the frequency of fasting in Ramadan in HD patients in Egypt and the possible effect of fasting on clinical and biochemical variables in a multicentric observational study carried out during 2016. They showed that fasting may be possible in maintenance HD. It may be recommended that HD patients should be encouraged to discuss the option of fasting in Ramadan with their HD staff who might be able to give advice on whether to allow them to fast on the days off dialysis. Close monitoring of dry body weight during HD sessions and restriction in potassium-containing diet in Ramadan must be considered the essential parts of patient care during Ramadan. Khazneh et al. examined the effects of RF on key biochemical and clinical markers among HD patients. In a prospective cohort study, 269 end-stage renal disease patients were recruited from the HD unit (Nablus, Palestine). The key clinical and biochemical markers were measured before, during, and after Ramadan. Their findings suggest that RF (fully or partially) is tolerable by HD patients and is not associated with critical clinical complications. However, these patients should be aware of the potential risk of fluid overload and hyperkalemia if they decide to fast during Ramadan. Thus, they should be closely monitored and instructed to adhere to their dietary and fluid intake allowances. Further information has been provided by Dogan et al. who investigated the effects of RF on renal functions in patients with Stage 3 and 4 chronic kidney disease (CKD). The patients were evaluated before Ramadan, the week immediately following Ramadan's end, and 3 and 6 months after Ramadan. Twenty-four fasting and 55 age-matched nonfasting individuals were included in the study. There was no statistically significant difference for creatinine levels in the 1st week after Ramadan in both groups compared to levels before Ramadan. The groups were compared according to the criteria of deterioration in renal function (reduction of 25% in glomerular filtration rate [GFR] and a 30% increase in serum creatinine levels). There were no statistically significant differences between the two groups according to these two criteria. In a regression analysis, diabetes mellitus and proteinuria were found to be independent risk determinants of renal dysfunction. Patients with diabetes mellitus and prominent proteinuria may constitute critical patient groups for renal function deterioration during RF. Adanan et al. evaluated the effects of RF on the nutritional and functional status of patients on maintenance HD in a 12-week, multicentric, prospective observational study. Nutritional and functional status assessments were carried out 2 weeks before (V0), in the 4th week of Ramadan (V1), and 4 weeks after Ramadan (V2). RF led to significant reductions in BMI, interdialytic weight gain, WC, mid-arm circumference, fat tissue mass, and BFP, but these were not accompanied by any significant change in lean tissue mass. Significant improvement was observed in serum phosphate levels. Serum albumin, urea, and creatinine reduced significantly during Ramadan. There were no significant changes in lipid profile and inflammatory markers. Interestingly, energy and protein intakes remain unchanged during Ramadan. Handgrip strength improved significantly during Ramadan and further improved after Ramadan. Intermittent RF leads to temporary changes in nutritional status parameters and poses a nondetrimental nutritional risk for patients on maintenance HD.
Three reviews addressed the impact of RF on CKD. The first review searched four databases using broad search terms with predefined eligibility criteria. Eight studies (549 patients) were identified as eligible; the studies measured renal function before and after Ramadan, with patients acting as their controls in five studies. The pooled analyses showed no significant changes after fasting with regard to estimated GFR or in serum creatinine levels. In four self-controlled studies (148 patients) that had analyzed changes in SBP and diastolic blood pressure before versus after fasting, no significant differences were shown. However, in three studies that assessed changes in GFR in fasting versus nonfasting patients, there was a significant difference in change in GFR following RF; however, these results were associated with significant publication bias (systematic heterogeneity). Fasting during Ramadan did not result in significant changes in kidney function or blood pressure in posttransplant patients with good baseline kidney function when patients acted as their controls. Furthermore, the second review studied the available evidence for patients with CKD and fasting, including HD and renal transplantation. The authors suggested that all patients with CKD should be deemed high risk or very high risk for fasting. However, they concluded that patients with stable mild/moderate CKD (Stages 1–3) may be able to fast, provided they are carefully monitored and counseled. They also suggest that patients with stable renal transplants may also be able to fast, providing they are monitored carefully by their transplant team. Patients on HD or peritoneal dialysis should not be encouraged to fast, but they will need careful weekly monitoring if they do so.
Impact of fasting and pregnancy and fetal life
Safari et al. assessed the following maternal outcomes: weight changes, gestational diabetes, preterm labor, preeclampsia, low birth weight, Apgar score, height, weight, and head circumference of the newborn during RF for those in their second trimester using a case–control study (Erbil, Iraq). Weight gain during pregnancy in fasting women was approximately 0.4 kg less than those who did not fast. The incidence of gestational diabetes was 2.6% in fasting women, while 8.3% in nonfasting mothers. Regression analysis showed that women not fasting during the second trimester of pregnancy were 1.51 times more likely to develop gestational diabetes. The authors concluded that fasting during the second trimester of pregnancy decreased the risk of gestational diabetes and excessive weight gain during pregnancy. Majid et al. studied gender-specific Ramadan consequences to the fetal environment in Indonesia, on birth weight, future performance on Raven's Colored Progressive Matrices (CPM), math scores, hours worked, and earnings. Full month of exposure to RF in utero led to significant reductions: among 8–15 years, lower scores on Raven's CPM tests for females and males; lower math scores for females and males. During the fetal period, events have far-reaching consequences for females and males in the lowest (10th and 25th) quantiles of outcome distributions, affecting the “relatively poor” the most. These results call for caution in interpreting studies on child development that rely on mean comparisons alone.
Several studies have reported adverse outcomes in adulthood for those prenatally exposed to RF. However, other studies document minimal to no impact on neonatal indicators. Kunto and Mandemakers used data from the Indonesian Family Life Survey consisting of 45,246 observations of 21,723 children born to 9771 mothers to examine the effects of “mother's religiosity” on stature from early childhood to late adolescence. Children were classified into three groups based on their mother's religion–religiosity: religious Muslims, less-religious Muslims, and non-Muslims. Using cluster-robust mother fixed-effects, they found adverse effects on stature for children born to religious Muslim mothers. The effects were age dependent and timing sensitive. For instance, children born to religious Muslim mothers were shorter in late adolescence compared to their unexposed siblings if they were prenatally exposed in the first trimester of pregnancy. Interestingly, they found positive effects on stature for exposed, less-religious Muslim children that peak in early adolescence, and adverse effects on stature for exposed non-Muslim children that occur only in early childhood. Makvandi et al. compared the basic hematological parameters of healthy fasting and nonfasting pregnant women 3 months after Ramadan. The fasters and nonfasters were similar in maternal age, gestational age, gravidity, prepregnancy weight, and maternal weight at enrollment. There were no statistically significant differences between the mean of hemoglobin, hematocrit, or other hematological parameters in the fasting and nonfasting groups.
Savitri et al. examined the Perinatal Registry of the Netherlands (Perined) on all births between 2000 and 2010 to mothers recorded as Mediterranean (i.e., of Turkish/Moroccan descent, a proxy for Muslim) or ethnically Dutch. Ramadan exposure was defined as the occurrence of a Ramadan during gestation. The study found that occurrence of Ramadan during pregnancy among Muslims was not associated with altered birth weight, gestational length, newborn's sex, perinatal mortality, low Apgar, or mild congenital anomalies. The study concluded that despite earlier research showing long-term adverse health effects of prenatal exposure to Ramadan, there seems to be little or no relation between exposure to Ramadan during pregnancy and birth outcomes. To aid decision-making on this subject, experts' opinion on this issue were surveyed. The survey was answered by 108 obstetricians and gynecologists. Most physicians recommended against fasting in the second and third trimesters, while fasting in the first trimester was controversial. Senior specialists were more lenient about fasting than younger specialists.
Tith et al. evaluated the association between RF during pregnancy and the risk of preterm birth for Arab women in Canada. They analyzed birth certificates from 3,123,508 deliveries in Quebec, Canada, from 1981 to 2017. They identified 78,109 births of Arabic-speaking women and determined if Ramadan occurred during any trimester of pregnancy. The study showed that Arabic speakers had an overall preterm birth rate of 5.53/100 births, but rates varied with Ramadan's timing. Fasting during Ramadan between weeks 15 and 21 of the second trimester was associated with 1.33 times the risk of very preterm birth relative to no fasting. Between weeks 22 and 27 of the second trimester, fasting during Ramadan was associated with 1.53 times the risk of very preterm birth. RF was not associated with extreme or late preterm birth regardless of the trimester of pregnancy. The study concluded that RF during the second pregnancy trimester was associated with the risk of very preterm birth.
Finally, to determine the impact of RF on fetal development, Zoukal and Hassoune systematically reviewed studies comparing the impact of fasting on fetal development in fasting and nonfasting pregnant women regardless of the stage of gestation. Ten studies met the research criteria and all were case–control. Studies were conducted in Turkey (6), Egypt (2), and Iran and Pakistan (1 each). Significant decreases in cephalic perimeter, biparietal diameter, and femoral length were noted in only one study. A change in the amniotic fluid index was observed in only two studies. The study showed that RF practiced by healthy pregnant women has no negative impact on fetal development.
Sports and athletes' well-being in Ramadan
Several groups developed academic interest in the impact of RF on physical work, athletes' performance, and well-being. Eleven articles were published in 2019; six reported original observations, four were systematic reviews, and one article provided a summary and recommendations. Omrane et al. quantified the physical workload during Ramadan 2015 (summer season) and verified if this load changes significantly compared with periods of nonfasting (in summer or winter seasons). The physical workload in the month of Ramadan was found to be medium and did not significantly differ from that noted in the nonfasting periods (outside of Ramadan). Gueldich et al. investigated RF impact on the underlying mechanisms of force production capacity during maximal voluntary isometric contraction using the superimposed twitch technique in ten healthy male physical education students before, during, and after Ramadan. The results showed that RF-related impairment of maximal muscle force seems to be related to nervous alterations of the voluntary activation level, whereas the RF did not adversely affect peripheral mechanisms. Hsouna et al. assessed changes in short-term maximal performance, alertness, dietary intake, sleep pattern, and mood states of physically active young men before, during, and after Ramadan observance in 12 physically active young men. Ramadan had no adverse effects on the 5-jump performance, alertness, or mood states in physically active young men. However, sleep duration was shorter, and sleep quality improved following Ramadan. The fractional intake of fat also increased at the expense of carbohydrate during Ramadan, and the protein intake was lower at the beginning of Ramadan than before, at the end of, and after Ramadan. Carling and Lugier examined the impact of RF on running activity profiles in elite soccer players during an official 90-min soccer match. Their results notably showed that players commencing play in a fasted state and completing 90 min generally coped physically, partly explained by nutritional intake during half-time and the adoption of a pacing strategy. Additional studies are nevertheless warranted using more controlled holistic experimental approaches and metrics (e.g., objective and subjective: physical/physiological/perceptual and technical) to improve the understanding of Ramadan's effects on performance, particularly over consecutive matches. The inclusion of larger sample sizes (teams + matches) is also necessary to better account for the large natural variability inherent to match running performance, and assess the effects of RF on recovery following a soccer match simulation. Bouzid et al. described eight elite soccer players who performed a modified Loughborough Intermittent Shuttle Test protocol on two occasions before and during Ramadan. Perturbations in physical performance and subjective rating parameters were higher at the end of Ramadan. However, this study's results showed that RF did not adversely affect the recovery following soccer match simulation in professional soccer players. Aziz et al. examined the extent to which RF affects badminton skill performance under simulated (i.e., competitive) match-play conditions. Ten male Muslim national-level badminton players performed a 40-min (2 sets ×20 min per set in each match) badminton single matches in a nonfasted (CON) and in Ramadan-fasted (RAM) state on separate occasions They demonstrated that although RF resulted in increased sensations of fatigue and tiredness during match-play, skill performances were however largely maintained, with the only observed decrement being a decrease in overhead smash velocity. Boukhris et al. evaluated the effect of RF on feelings, dietary intake, rating of perceived exertion, and repeated high-intensity, short-term maximal performance in 13 physically active young nonobese men. RF has no adverse effect on feelings, dietary intake, and short-term maximal performance. However, the rating of perceived exertion during repeated high-intensity, short-term maximal exercise reduced at twenty days after Ramadan in comparison to last 10 days of Ramadan.
Four systematic reviews addressed the different aspects of sports medicine.,,, Fernando et al. examined the effect of RF on weight and body composition before and after Ramadan after excluding the effect of diet and physical activity. There was a significant positive correlation between starting BMI and weight loss during the fasting period. Consistently, there was a significant reduction in fat percentage between pre-Ramadan and post-Ramadan in people with overweight or obesity, but not in those of normal weight. At 2–5 weeks after Ramadan's end, there was a return toward, or to, pre-Ramadan measurements in weight and body composition. Chtourou et al. evaluated Ramadan's fasting on physical performance measures in soccer players through a systematic appraisal of the literature from two databases. Most studies showed that RF did not impair short-term maximal performances in soccer players (i.e., vertical jump, sprint performance, maximal voluntary contraction, handgrip, and agility performance). The continuance of training during RF, with maintained training load, had no adverse effects on short-term maximal performances and soccer-specific skills. However, the 30-s Wingate test performances, the RSE tasks, and the long-duration incremental and nonincremental exercises were significantly impaired during RF even when the training load was maintained. Trabelsi et al. evaluated the effects of RF on hematological data in athletes through a systematic appraisal of the literature. Ramadan-related measurements of any hematological indices in athletes were considered. Compared to before Ramadan, hematocrit and hemoglobin values increased in three studies, decreased in one study, and did not change during RF. Another study reported increased hematocrit and a puzzling decrease of hemoglobin after Ramadan compared to before RF. In most studies, blood platelet counts, and the limited number of immune functions used to date, remained unchanged. All reported changes in hematological indices remained within the normal reference range of the laboratory. Therefore, regular training can continue safely during RF from a hematological viewpoint. Aloui et al. assessed the effects of RF on body composition in athletes. Data from 12 studies met the inclusion criteria for this review, which involved 183 athletes of different sport disciplines. The analyzed studies collectively indicate that BMI and BFP are generally lower during Ramadan than before Ramadan, while lean mass and total body water remain unchanged during Ramadan. Despite the importance of body composition control in sport and exercise settings, there are still many aspects of body composition that should be more thoroughly assessed in athletes during Ramadan. More research, especially well-conducted randomized controlled trials, are needed to evaluate the magnitude of body composition changes in athletes during Ramadan.
Chamari et al. provided practical recommendations based on an updated, evidence-based synthesis of the existing scholarly literature and/or expert opinions on the topic and subsequently, some useful tips for athletes, coaches, medical and scientific support, and sports managers, in order to guide them on how to promote appropriate behavioral, social, and psychological strategies to cope with the changes and potential constraints induced by the observance of RF. These recommendations should be adjusted and coped with, utilizing a holistic approach, rather than on single alteration/perturbation. Moreover, the implemented strategies should not be “one-size-fits-all” approach. It should instead take into account the variability among athletes and their specific needs including their social and living environment, as it may be more challenging when the individual is performing RF in a predominantly non-Muslim majority country.
Changes in the structure and function of the eye during fasting
Armstrong et al. evaluated Ramadan's fasting on the level of tear film matrix metalloproteinase-9 (MMP-9) and other standard indicators of dry eye disease in forty healthy patients without a history of ocular disease before and during Ramadan. Ocular Surface Disease Index scores, tear breakup time (TBUT), Schirmer I test, and corneal fluorescein staining were evaluated at each time point. InflammaDry positivity increased during RF. The mean TBUT decreased during RF. The authors recommended that patients who suffer from dry eye disease and those who develop symptoms during Ramadan are advised to seek medical advice. Uyar et al. assessed Ramadan's fasting on choroidal thickness (CT) and its associated diurnal variations using spectral-domain-optical coherence tomography in a single eye of 87 healthy individuals twice a day around 8.00 a.m. and during and 1 month following Ramadan. Measurements of CT and retinal thickness were performed at central, temporal, and nasal segments. The comparison of measurements revealed that temporal CT in the morning and foveal, temporal, and nasal CTs at afternoon significantly reduced during fasting. Diurnal variations of foveal and temporal CTs during fasting were significantly higher than that of the controls. In addition, retinal thicknesses during fasting significantly reduced compared to that of the controls in all segments measured at 4.00 p.m. The results suggest that fasting and dehydration caused a reduction of the CT and retinal thickness. Similarly, they are also responsible for the increased diurnal variation of CTs. Ekici Gok et al. evaluated the effect of fasting on contrast sensitivity (CS) during RF in 45 healthy male individuals aged between 20 and 40 years, working in the same environment. Functional acuity contrast testing was performed. CS increased at the spatial frequency of three cycles per degree (cpd) at the end of the 1st week of Ramadan in comparison to the CS measured before Ramadan. The mean CS values increased at the spatial frequencies of 3 and 12 cpd at the end of the last week of Ramadan in comparison to the mean values measured before Ramadan. However, the authors could not confirm that RF has an adverse effect on CS. Finally, in a prospective study, Duru examined 34 healthy eyes. The choroidal, macular, and retinal nerve fiber layer thicknesses were measured using spectral-domain-optical coherence tomography. The results revealed that RF is associated with alterations in choroidal and paracentral macular thickness in healthy volunteers. However, more detailed investigations should be designed to evaluate whether fasting has a pivotal influence on pathological conditions.
Gut and liver in Ramadan
Several studies investigated the effects of RF on gut and liver functions, and related parameters. Rimmani et al. investigated the efficacy of dexlansoprazole 60 mg during Ramadan in patients with symptomatic heartburn by incorporating a mean Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Questionnaire (GERDQ). Dexlansoprazole was started on day 8 for 3 weeks. The primary end point was relief of heartburn expressed as mean 24-h free heartburn percentage (24FH%) per weekly period. On dexlansoprazole, 24FH% increased in weeks 2 and 4. The mean GERDQ scores decreased in weeks 2 and 4 and the mean heartburn severity score decreased. Early response was higher in patients with GERDQ scores ≥8. Dexlansoprazole has the potential of reducing heartburn during Ramadan. Ebrahimi et al. determined the effects of RF on liver function, Visceral Adiposity Index (VAI), and Atherogenic Index of Plasma (AIP) in fasting and nonfasting subjects with NAFLD. Anthropometric and biochemical parameters and ultrasound grading were measured before and after Ramadan. The mean decreases in anthropometric indices were significantly different between groups. The values of AIP and VAI decreased at the end of the study in both groups, and the mean of changes showed no differences between groups. The changes in the concentrations of liver enzymes, as well as the severity of hepatic steatosis, showed remarkable differences between groups for serum glutamic oxaloacetic transaminase and serum glutamic pyruvic transaminase, and liver steatosis. Özkul et al. enrolled nine subjects in a study during Ramadan to assess changes in stool microflora and associated nutrition parameters. Stool samples were collected at baseline and at the end of Ramadan. They found an abundance of Akkermansia muciniphila and Bacteroides fragilis group but a significant decrease in serum fasting glucose (FG) and TC levels in subjects. These findings may contribute to the understanding of fasting–gut microbiota interaction. Jarrar et al. evaluated satiety, bowel habits, body composition, blood glycemia, and blood lipidemia after the consumption of high-fiber cereal at dawn during RF. Participants were randomized to consume either 90 g of high-fiber cereal at Sohour for 20 consecutive days (n = 45) or to maintain their habitual diet intake (control; n = 36). The intervention group reported higher satiety rating scores, improved bowel habits, and reduced bloating frequency after the 20-day intervention. Significantly higher intake of carbohydrates and dietary fiber was observed in the intervention group. TC and LDL-C were significantly lower among the intervention group compared to those of the control group. No significant differences in body weight, BFP, WC, BMI, blood glucose, HDL-C, or TG were observed between the two groups.
Spirometry and management of asthma in Ramadan
A few articles have addressed the impact of RF on pulmonary functions in healthy people and in patients with bronchial asthma. Ben Fraj et al. studied the spirometric data of a group of fasting and age-matched nonfasting Tunisian healthy male adolescents in a comparative quasi-experimental study during Ramadan of 2015. Spirometry measurements were taken on three sessions (before, mid, and after Ramadan). There were no effects of RF on forced vital capacity, forced expiratory volume, peak expiratory flow, or maximal mid-expiratory flow between the fasting and nonfasting groups. Mohammad et al. reviewed the Islamic jurisprudence rulings on whether inhalers invalidate fasting or not. Some Muslim scholars believe that inhalers do not break the fast because of the gaseous nature of the inhaled agents. Other scholars disagree. It is important to assist patients in dealing with this dilemma. One approach is to help patients with the timing of their inhaler use. Most preventive asthma medications are prescribed twice daily. With good timing, patients can stick to their therapeutic regimens and still observe fasting. The authors stressed that physicians should educate patients about the importance of adherence to preventive therapy during the month of Ramadan to avoid precipitation of attacks and remind patients of the divine exemptions for those with serious medical conditions. The latter may be a golden opportunity for patients to stop smoking, a process that can be enhanced by compassionate education from the physician. The authors also recommended incorporating “Asthma in Ramadan” in the education curriculum of nursing, pharmacy, and medical schools.
Impact of fasting on skin, skeleton, and blood
Several groups have investigated the impact of RF on common skin and skeletal conditions and anticoagulation therapy. Patients with various health problems, including those with different skin disorders, might choose to share this event with peers and family members. Bragazzi et al. carried out a comprehensive overview on the topic covering all forms of fasting including RF. Damiani et al. described the effect of RF in 55 patients with a relatively long duration of hidradenitis suppurativa (HS). RF proved to be safe and effective in HS patients. Considering the small sample size and the exploratory nature of the investigation, further studies in the field are warranted, especially longitudinal, prospective, and randomized ones. The same group also evaluated a sample of 108 moderate-to-severe plaque psoriasis patients. A significant decrease in the “Psoriasis Area and Severity Index” (PASI) score after RF was seen. These findings reflect the influence of dieting strategy, the biological clock, and circadian rhythm on the treatment of plaque psoriasis. Furthermore, the association between nutritional intake and sleeping pattern during Ramadan with sebum production was explored in forty individuals evaluated before and 3 weeks into RF. Parameters assessed included nutrient intake, sleep quality, and duration of sebum production. Significant decreases were found in protein and total fat intake. Glycemic load also decreased significantly. Despite no reduction seen in total sleep duration, night sleep deprivation occurring during Ramadan was associated with more subjects having poor sleep quality. Despite lower glycemic load and dairy product intake, RF was associated with increased sebum production which is more likely a result of the circadian rhythm shift in sebaceous gland activities.
To determine the effect of RF on arthritic conditions, Adawi et al. enrolled 37 patients with psoriatic arthritis (PsA) who fasted for 17 h during Ramadan, 2016. The study participants were treated with different biologic agents including methotrexate, TNF-α blockers, and IL-17 blockers. After a month of IF, CRP levels, Bath Ankylosing Spondylitis Disease Activity Index, PASI, and Disease Activity Index for PsA decreased. Similarly, enthesitis improved after fasting, with decreased Leeds Enthesitis Index (LEI) score and dactylitis severity score. Fasting was found to be a predictor of a decrease in PsA disease activity scores. IL-17 therapy was found to be an independent predictor of decreases in LEI after fasting. These preliminary data may support the use of chronomedicine in the context of rheumatic diseases, namely PsA. Further studies are needed to support their findings.
Patients on anticoagulation therapies might be at risk of fluctuations during RF. Zghal Mghaieth et al. compared the fluctuations of anticoagulation in fasting and nonfasting patients taking acenocoumarol to identify factors associated with such fluctuations before, during, and after Ramadan. The enrollment involved ambulatory patients aged over 18, without medical contraindications to fasting (for the fasting group), and whose international normalized ratio (INR) was within the therapeutic target range in the 3 months prior to Ramadan. Anticoagulation monitoring consisted of five consecutive INR assays before, during, and after Ramadan. INR stability was calculated for 122 patients (84 fasting patients). The fluctuations of anticoagulation balance were comparable between fasting and nonfasting patients taking acenocoumarol. Ghiasian et al. evaluated the effect and prognosis of fasting in 58 patients with cerebral venous thrombosis (CVT) using oral-combined contraceptives (OCPs). Fasting in patients using OCPs caused significantly higher focal neurological deficit and higher hemorrhage. At discharge, 51.6% and after 3 months, 25.8% of patients with fasting had disability (6> modified Rankin Scale >1). Patients who used OCPs as a sole risk factor, 25.9%, at discharge and after 3 months (11.1%) had a disability. Fasting in patients with CVT using OCPs causes a significant increase in focal neurological deficit and hemorrhage, which also increases the hospital stay and lengthens recovery. However, the long-term prognosis and mortality of CVT were similar between the two groups.
Effects of Ramadan on endocrine and metabolic conditions
Two aspects of endocrinology (other than diabetes) were published. One considered thyroxine replacement therapy and the other impact on the components of metabolic syndrome (MetS). Dabbous et al. compared two time points of levothyroxine intake during Ramadan in terms of change in thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH), compliance, and convenience. Using an open-label, randomized, prospective trial on 96 adult patients with primary hypothyroidism and stable TSH for 6 months, patients were randomized to two groups: 50 patients took levothyroxine 30 min before breaking the fast at sunset (Group A), whereas 46 patients took it 30 min before the early morning meal before dawn (Group B). TSH levels increased in both groups after RF. The authors did not detect any difference between the two groups in terms of compliance or convenience in the timing of taking the medication.
Studies on the impact of RF on MetS components among healthy Muslims observing Ramadan month have yielded contradictory results. Faris et al. aimed to obtain a more stable estimate of the effect size of fasting during Ramadan on MetS components, examine variability among studies, assess the generalizability of reported results, and perform subgroup analyses for associated factors. They identified 85 studies (4326 participants in total) conducted in 23 countries between 1982 and 2019. RF-induced effect sizes for MetS components were small reductions in WC, SBP, FG, and TGs and a small increase in HDL-C. They concluded that among healthy people, RF shows small improvements in the five MetS components, namely WC, SBP, TG, FG, and HDL and also better post main meal control in Ramadan, without affecting HbA1c, or increasing the incidence of hypoglycemia.
Three original studies considered various aspects of metabolism.,, Beltaief et al. studied 517 patients with ≥2 cardiovascular risk factors before, during, and after Ramadan. They noted a significant and discrete rise in blood glucose level, TG, cholesterol, and creatinine during Ramadan. These disturbances decreased significantly after Ramadan. The same variations were observed among people with diabetes (n = 323). HbA1c decreased significantly after Ramadan. They found no significant correlation between variations of metabolic parameters and dietary intake. The authors concluded that Ramadan induces a transient but well-tolerated perturbation of metabolic parameters followed by a significant post-Ramadan improvement. These changes did not seem to be directly related to dietary intake. Faris et al. examined the impact of RF on visceral adiposity, circulating adipokines, and glucoregulatory markers in patients with overweight or obesity. Body weight, visceral fat tissue area (measured by 3D-MRI), glucoregulatory factors, serum adipokine concentrations, dietary intake, and physical activity were assessed 1 week before and at the end of Ramadan. Body weight, visceral fat tissue area, serum TC, TG, HDL-C, and SBP significantly decreased at the end of Ramadan. Serum levels of adiponectin, IL-6, TNF-α, and IGF-1 also significantly decreased, but serum visfatin, leptin, apelin, IL-10, and IL-10/IL-6 ratio significantly increased at the end of Ramadan. Changes in visceral adiposity significantly correlated with changes in plasma glucose. Madkour et al. evaluated the impact of RF on the expression of cellular metabolism (SIRT1 and SIRT3) and antioxidant genes (TFAM, SOD2, and Nrf2). They showed that the relative gene expressions in subjects with obesity in comparison to the counterpart expressions of controls for the antioxidant genes significantly increased at the end of Ramadan. However, the metabolism-controlling gene (SIRT3) showed a highly significant downregulation accompanied by a trend for reduction in the SIRT1 gene at the end of Ramadan. These results suggest that RF ameliorates the genetic expression of antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and metabolic regulatory genes.
Fasting and neurological disorders
The impact of Ramadan on neurological diseases and their related factors also drew interest in the 2019 literature. Specific disease states were investigated by three research groups which included control of Parkinson's disease (PD) and the effects of RF on postural control in elderly fallers and nonfallers. Tabrizi and Karimi compared the incidence of neurological diseases and their related factors in Ramadan and the following month (Shawal) in 2015. They found no significant difference between the 2 months in the frequency of admissions due to neurologic diseases. In another study, Kamel et al. observed a group of 24 patients with PD who had planned to fast during the Ramadan of 2016. Twenty patients fasted during the whole month. Six were able to abstain from drug intake from dawn to dusk; the others needed one or two intakes of L-DOPA during the day. Compared to before Ramadan, there were no significant changes after the fasting period in the quality of life (PDQ 39), Non-Motor Symptom Scale, or Clinical Impression of Severity Index scores. Finally, Laater et al. compared the effects of RF on postural control in elderly fallers and nonfallers. The protocol involved 24 healthy elderly male volunteers who were divided into two groups: fallers and nonfallers. The results showed that RF alters the postural control of elderly fallers and nonfallers equally, but the amplitude of this alteration seems to be more pronounced in fallers than nonfallers.
Mental well-being in Ramadan
Two original studies and one systematic review addressed the mental well-being during RF., Düzçeker et al. examined the cross-sectional relationship between RF as a spiritual factor with prolonged hunger and disordered eating behaviors. The study was conducted in June 2016 and consisted of 238 fasting and 49 nonfasting adolescents. The risk of disordered eating, body image dissatisfaction, and nutritional status was assessed. The study suggests that because the motivation of adolescents to fast during Ramadan was due to spiritual decisions rather than weight control or other factors, RF did not correlate with disordered eating behaviors or body image dissatisfaction. Briki et al. examined how RF could influence positive and negative feelings in 91 healthy Muslims. They voluntarily completed an online questionnaire once a week during 8 weeks before, during, and after Ramadan (2013) at the middle of the day. The results showed that RF was associated with lower levels of positive affect, negative affect, and depression. However, anxiety and well-being were not influenced by RF. This study suggests that RF would act as a buffer against the intensity of emotions. Pourabbasi et al. performed a systematic review to evaluate the relationship between Islamic fasting and cognitive activities. The findings were inconclusive, and this might be an interesting area for further research with larger sample sizes and better evaluation tools.
Sleep pattern and quality during Ramadan
The interplay of RF with several aspects of sleep physiology was addressed by several authors in two original articles and two systematic reviews. Boukhris et al. examined sleep and alertness during Ramadan observance in 14 young, physically active men. Information was also collected on dietary intake, muscle soreness, fatigue, and mental stress. They concluded that Ramadan observance had an adverse effect on sleep quantity and mental alertness, but not on sleep quality. However, dietary intake, muscle soreness, fatigue, and mental stress remained unaffected. Almeneessier et al. performed a quantitative electroencephalogram (EEG) analysis of eight young, healthy volunteers with and without fasting. The authors demonstrated that during wakefulness, there was no difference in EEG slowing or absolute powers in the delta, theta, alpha, and beta frequency bands between nonfasting and fasting subjects. Spectral analysis of EEG power indicates that intermittent diurnal fasting does not increase sleepiness, but future larger studies are needed to confirm the current findings.
Two systematic reviews evaluated the impact of RF on sleep patterns with conflicting results. Faris et al. analyzed several sleep quality measures based on 24 studies (646 participants) conducted in 12 countries from 2001 to 2019. The authors concluded that during the month of Ramadan, there is approximately a 1-h reduction in total sleep time (TST) and nearly a 1-point increase in the Epworth Sleepiness Scale. On the other hand, Trabelsi et al. included 13 studies evaluating the TST of active individuals in relation to RF and found that TST decreased in five studies, increased in one, and remained unchanged in seven studies. As no firm conclusions could be drawn regarding sleep quality or characteristics, further studies are warranted.
Ramadan-related cultural and professional perspectives
Three aspects of professional–patient interaction were addressed in four articles. Patients' perspectives on communicating with clinicians were explored by Amin et al. in two different papers., In the first, they explored Muslims' perspectives on factors influencing communication with clinicians concerning fasting during Ramadan. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with a sample of patients. Data emerging from narratives were mapped and clustered into patient participation and quality of care; predisposing factors (perceptions about fasting and its significance including a sense of spiritual benefit when fasting and sense of guilt when not fasting, prior experiences including prior conversations with clinicians on fasting and experience of fasting while sick, patients' personality and locus of control, belief in the legitimacy of participation, motivations and perception of the need to communicate with clinicians about fasting, provider verbal and nonverbal responses, and provider–patient rapport) and enabling factors (knowledge about the topic and repertoire of communicative skills, presence of companions during the appointment, and timing of appointments). The framework provided insight into patients' perspectives on barriers and facilitators for communication with clinicians about fasting during Ramadan. Stakeholders must consider those issues when implementing interventions aiming to adopt a concordant approach in providing care for this group of patients. In the second paper, the authors mapped data into clinician's belief to care for those patients, belief in group's ability to provide care, likely consequences of providing such care, knowledge, learning by observing other clinicians, cultural norms and perceived acceptability and prevalence of care provision, environmental barriers and opportunities, and communication approach. Ben Saida et al. investigated the impacts of Ramadan on intensive care unit (ICU) admission patterns and outcomes in a retrospective study from Tunisia. Of the 748 patients who were admitted to the ICU before, during, and after Ramadan over 10 years, the number of patients with CKD and those admitted with hypovolemic shock was significantly higher. However, there was no significant difference in length of stay or mortality.
Concerns about the health effects of RF and the risks of work-related injuries have increased in Western European (EURO) countries. Riccò et al. performed a retrospective database-based analysis assessing the impact of RF on occupational injuries (OIs) in North-Eastern Italy among migrant workers from the Eastern Mediterranean Regional Office (EMRO). They suggested that EMRO workers exhibit a significantly increased risk for OIs during Ramadan in periods characterized by heat waves, while their frequency somehow reduced for days associated with Ramadan characterized by increased but not extreme temperatures. However, these results may be attributable to explanatory causation in the specific differences between EMRO and EURO workers in the job tasks performed at the workplace. Not coincidentally, no significant differences were found regarding industrial settings, mechanisms of OIs, or final prognosis. Despite the obvious practical implications for health decision makers and policymakers, due to the limitations of the present investigation, further studies are warranted. Kankou et al. examined the factors associated with the virological rebound (VR) at the occasion of a temporary stay to the country of origin for HIV-positive migrants from the sub-Saharan Africa participating in the ANRS-VIHVO adherence study between 2006 and 2009. They included patients on effective antiretroviral therapy with controlled pretravel HIV-1 plasma viral load. They found that traveling during Ramadan while observing the fast and extension of the stay were both associated with VR. The authors inferred that VR was partly explained by structural barriers to adherence such as the extension of the travel and inadequate management of RF. Individuals' journeys should be carefully planned with health-care providers.
Faith-related health-care needs are generally not formally addressed in the medical curricula. Therefore, Haq et al. recommend additional content that would better tailor the undergraduate curriculum to cater to the needs of this large cohort of Muslim patients with the expectation that patients would have their faith-related health queries resolved by health-care providers. Based on a survey of select academics, the authors suggested that (a) the topics proposed were, in fact, legitimate faith-related health-care needs of Muslim patients, and (b) their inclusion would add value to the undergraduate medical curriculum and train practitioners to improve patient outcomes more holistically.
| Conclusions|| |
The interest in the implications of RF for health outcomes continues. Although fasting for healthy adults is an article of faith, there is still a lot that can be learned from studies on how fasting may affect people in sickness or in certain stages of life such as childhood, elderly, pregnancy, or in times of hardship such as traveling and adverse weather circumstances. Through these studies, we can gather better evidence rather than rely on consensus. Impact of RF on physiology, nutrition, pregnancy, and athletes' well-being received comparatively prominent coverage by research work published in 2019. Renal function, eyes, and some metabolic concerns in patients with hepatic and metabolic conditions were also covered. Some interest in cultural and professional aspects of care for fasting people was also published. The volume remains modest when the number of people involved is taken into consideration. By reviewing all the literature published in a full year of 2019, we hope to provide a bird's eye view of the subject for those who need to catch up on the state-of-the-art today.
All authors contributed to the conception of the study. SAB performed the initial literature searches and produced the initial draft. All authors further developed their assigned sections and reviewed the whole manuscript for intellectual content and approved its final version.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
Compliance with ethical principles
No ethical approval is required.
| References|| |
Beshyah SA. Fasting during the month of Ramadan for people with diabetes: Medicine and Fiqh united at last. Ibnosina J Med Biomed Sci 2009;1:58-60. [Full text]
Sherif IH, Lakhdar AA. Ramadan fasting and the medical patient: Consensus is welcome, but more evidence is needed. Ibnosina J Med Biomed Sci 2010;2:237-93. [Full text]
Khalil AB, Lakhdar AA, Benbarka MM, Sherif IH. Research and Ramadan fasting: Not too much of a good thing! Ibnosina J Med Biomed Sci 2018;10:35-6.
Beshyah SA, Hajjaji IM, Ibrahim WH, Deeb A, El-Ghul EM, Akkari KB, et al.
The year in Ramadan fasting research (2017): A narrative review. Ibnosina J Med Biomed Sci 2018;10:39-53. [Full text]
Beshyah SA, Badi A, El-Ghul AM, Ghabroun A, Doughman KK, Eledrisis MS. Special communication: The year in Ramadan fasting and health. Ibnosina J Med Biomed Sci 2019;11:151-70. [Full text]
Beshyah SA, Ali KF, Hafidh K, Hajjaji IM. Ramadan fasting and diabetes 2019: The year in review. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 2020:108593. doi: 10.1016/j.diabres.2020.108593. Epub ahead of print.
Akın S, Özer FF, Şahin GG, Özer NT. Effects of Ramadan fasting on lean body mass in the older people. Eur Geriatr Med 2020;11:163-8.
Rahbar AR, Safavi E, Rooholamini M, Jaafari F, Darvishi S, Rahbar A. Effects of intermittent fasting during Ramadan on insulin-like growth factor-1, interleukin 2, and lipid profile in healthy Muslims. Int J Prev Med 2019;10:7.
] [Full text]
Alzoughool F, Al Hourani H, Atoum M, Abdelgader R, Alanagreh L. Irisin, leptin and adiponectin levels are reduced significantly during fasting. Mediterr J Nutr Metab 2019;12:389-96.
Culha C, Gorar S, Aral Y. Circulating obestatin levels during Ramadan fasting in normal weight and obese subjects. Kuwait Med J 2019;51:335-40.
Manjunath G, Aravindhakshan R, Varghese S. Effect of fasting during Ramadan on thermal stress parameters. East Mediterr Health J 2019;25:34-9.
Ahmed OA. Effect of Ramadan fasting on red and white blood cell parameters in healthy females. Gazi Med J 2019;30:1-3.
Razzak AR, Mohamed MW, Alshaiji AF, Qareeballa AA, Bagust J, Docherty S. Is spatial orientation affected by Ramadan fasting? Nutr Food Sci 2019;49:464-75.
Iqbal M, Jamea AA, Alonso AM, Al-Regaiey KA, Bashir S. Cortical thickness, neurocognitive, and body composition effects of fasting during Ramadan. J Res Med Sci 2019;24:50.
] [Full text]
Nachvak SM, Pasdar Y, Pirsaheb S, Darbandi M, Niazi P, Mostafai R, et al
. Effects of Ramadan on food intake, glucose homeostasis, lipid profiles and body composition. Eur J Clin Nutr 2019;73:594-600.
Ben Jemaa H, Mahjoub F, Berriche O, Gammoudi A, Chaabouni S, Jamoussi H. Impacts of nutritional education before Ramadan fasting on dietary intake, weight and body composition in diabetic patients. Tunis Med 2019;97:1139-45.
Das A, Hasmat N, Ghosh KS, Sahu S. Effects of Ramadan intermittent fasting and pattern of nutrients intake on BMI and MUAC of a population consisting of Indian Muslims. Biol Rhythm Res 2019. DOI: 10.1080/09291016.2019.1700328.
Paoli A, Tinsley G, Bianco A, Moro T. The influence of meal frequency and timing on health in humans: The role of fasting. Nutrients 2019;11:719.
Pak M, Buyukuslu N. The gender differentiation affects the nutritional status and biochemical characteristics during Ramadan fasting. Kuwait Med J 2019;51:172-80.
Ismail S, Manaf RA, Mahmud A. Comparison of time-restricted feeding and Islamic fasting: A scoping review. East Mediterr Health J 2019;25:239-45.
Lessan N, Ali T. Energy metabolism and intermittent fasting: The Ramadan perspective. Nutrients 2019;11:E1192.
Mirmiran P, Bahadoran Z, Gaeini Z, Moslehi N, Azizi F. Effects of Ramadan intermittent fasting on lipid and lipoprotein parameters: An updated meta-analysis. Nutr Metab Cardiovasc Dis 2019;29:906-15.
Karsen H, Güler EA, Binici İ, Taşkıran H, Yıldırım S, Koyuncu İ. Oxidant and antioxidant parameters in people who fast during Ramadan, and those who do not. Afr Health Sci 2019;19:2713-7.
Almeneessier AS, BaHammam AA, Alzoghaibi M, Olaish AH, Nashwan SZ, BaHammam AS. The effects of diurnal intermittent fasting on proinflammatory cytokine levels while controlling for sleep/wake pattern, meal composition and energy expenditure. PLoS One 2019;14:e0226034.
Mushtaq R, Akram A, Mushtaq R, Khwaja S, Ahmed S. The role of inflammatory markers following Ramadan Fasting. Pak J Med Sci 2019;35:77-81.
Mrad S, Rejeb H, Ben Abdallah J, Graiet H, Ben Khelifa M, Abed A, et al.
The impacts of Ramadan intermittent fasting on oxidant/antioxidant stress biomarkers of stable chronic obstructive pulmonary disease male patients. Am J Mens Health 2019;13:1557988319848281.
Ben Ayed H, Koubaa M, Ben Jemaa M, Hammemi F, Rekik K, Ben Jemaa T, et al
. Prognosis of urinary tract infections: Predictive factors and role of Ramadan fasting. Tunis Med 2019;97:1169-76.
Faris MA, Jahrami HA, Obaideen AA, Madkour MI. Impact of diurnal intermittent fasting during Ramadan on inflammatory and oxidative stress markers in healthy people: Systematic review and meta-analysis. J Nutr Intermediary Metab 2019;15:18-26.
Tashkandi B, Kaur D, Latifi E, Tallman DA, Chinna K, Daud ZAM, et al
. Lipids, lipoprotein distribution and nutritional parameters over the Ramadan period in hemodialysis patients. Nutrients 2019;11:2225.
Megahed AF, El-Kannishy G, Sayed-Ahmed N. Status of fasting in Ramadan of chronic hemodialysis patients all over Egypt: A multicenter observational study. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl 2019;30:339-49.
] [Full text]
Khazneh E, Qaddumi J, Hamdan Z, Qudaimat F, Sbitany A, Jebrin K, et al
. The effects of Ramadan fasting on clinical and biochemical markers among hemodialysis patients: A prospective cohort study. PLoS One 2019;14:e0218745.
Dogan I, Eser B, Kayadibi H. The effect of Ramadan fasting on renal functions in patients with chronic kidney disease. Turk J Biochem 2019;44:189-96.
Adanan NI, Md Ali MS, Lim JH, Zakaria NF, Lim CTS, Yahya R, et al
. Investigating Physical and nutritional changes during prolonged intermittent fasting in hemodialysis patients: A prospective cohort study. J Ren Nutr 2020;30:e15-26.
Binsalih S, Al Sayyari RA, Sheikho M, Hejaili FF, Al Sayyari AA. Effect of fasting the whole month of Ramadan on renal function among Muslim patients with kidney transplant: A meta-analysis. Exp Clin Transplant 2019;17:588-93.
Ahmad S, Chowdhury TA. Fasting during Ramadan in people with chronic kidney disease: A review of the literature. Ther Adv Endocrinol Metab 2019;10:2042018819889019.
Safari K, Piro TJ, Ahmad HM. Perspectives and pregnancy outcomes of maternal Ramadan fasting in the second trimester of pregnancy. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2019;19:128.
Majid F, Behrman J, Mani S. Short-term and long-term distributional consequences of prenatal malnutrition and stress: Using Ramadan as a natural experiment. BMJ Glob Health 2019;4:e001185.
Kunto YS, Mandemakers JJ. The effects of prenatal exposure to Ramadan on stature during childhood and adolescence: Evidence from the Indonesian family life survey. Econ Hum Biol 2019;33:29-39.
Makvandi S, Karimi L, Mahdavian M, Bastami A. No differences in hematological parameters of fasting and non-fasting pregnant women three months after Ramadan. Int J Vitam Nutr Res 2018;88:258-62.
Savitri AI, Painter RC, Lindeboom M, Roseboom TJ, van Ewijk RJ. Ramadan exposure and birth outcomes: A population-based study from the Netherlands. J Dev Orig Health Dis 2020;11:664-71.
Adler-Lazarovits C, Weintraub AY. Physicians' attitudes and views regarding religious fasting during pregnancy and review of the literature. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 2019;233:76-80.
Tith RM, Bilodeau-Bertrand M, Lee GE, Healy-Profitós J, Auger N. Fasting during Ramadan increases risk of very preterm birth among Arabic-speaking women. J Nutr 2019;149:1826-32.
Zoukal S, Hassoune S. The effects of Ramadan fasting during pregnancy on fetal development: A general review. Tunis Med 2019;97:1132-8.
Omrane A, Kammoun S, Mili H, Khalfallah T, El Mhamdi S, Bouzgarrou L. Does Ramadan fasting affect the physical workload? Tunis Med 2019;97:1146-52.
Gueldich H, Zghal F, Borji R, Chtourou H, Sahli S, Rebai H. The effects of Ramadan intermittent fasting on the underlying mechanisms of force production capacity during maximal isometric voluntary contraction. Chronobiol Int 2019;36:698-708.
Hsouna H, Abdessalem R, Boukhris O, Trabelsi K, Chtourou L, Tahri N, et al
. Short-term maximal performance, alertness, dietary intake, sleep pattern and mood states of physically active young men before, during and after Ramadan observance. PLoS One 2019;14:e0217851.
Carling C, Lugier J. Effects of Ramadan fasting on running activity profiles in elite soccer players during an official 90-minute match. J Sports Sci Med 2019;18:387-9.
Bouzid MA, Abaïdia AE, Bouchiba M, Ghattassi K, Daab W, Engel FA, et al
. Effects of Ramadan fasting on recovery following a simulated soccer match in professional soccer players: A pilot study. Front Physiol 2019;10:1480.
Aziz AR, Lim DS, Sahrom S, Che Muhamed AM, Ihsan M, Girard O, et al
. Effects of Ramadan fasting on match-related changes in skill performance in elite Muslim badminton players. Sci Sports 2020; 35:308.e1-308.e10.
Boukhris O, Hsouna H, Chtourou L, Abdesalem R, BenSalem S, Tahri N, et al
. Effect of Ramadan fasting on feelings, dietary intake, rating of perceived exertion and repeated high intensity short-term maximal performance. Chronobiol Int 2019;36:1-0.
Fernando HA, Zibellini J, Harris RA, Seimon RV, Sainsbury A. Effect of Ramadan fasting on weight and body composition in healthy non-athlete adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Nutrients 2019;11:E478.
Chtourou H, Trabelsi K, Boukhris O, Ammar A, Shephard RJ, Bragazzi NL. Effects of Ramadan fasting on physical performances in soccer players: A systematic review. Tunis Med 2019;97:1114-31.
Trabelsi K, Shephard RJ, Boukhris O, Ammar A, El-Abed K, Khanfir S, et al
. Effects of Ramadan fasting on athletes' hematological indices: A systematic review. Tunis Med 2019;97:1104-13.
Aloui A, Baklouti H, Souissi N, Chtourou H. Effects of Ramadan fasting on body composition in athletes: A systematic review. Tunis Med 2019;97:1087-94.
Chamari K, Roussi M, Bragazzi NL, Chaouachi A, Abdul RA. Optimizing training and competition during the month of Ramadan: Recommendations for a holistic and personalized approach for the fasting athletes. Tunis Med 2019;97:1095-103.
Armstrong BK, Coc IR, Agarwal P, Smith S, Navon S. Association of Ramadan daytime fasting with ocular surface inflammation and dry eye. Int Ophthalmol 2019;39:2857-63.
Uyar E, Dogan U, Ulas F, Celebi S. Effect of fasting on choroidal thickness and its diurnal variation. Curr Eye Res 2019;44:695-700.
Ekici Gok Z, Gunduz A, Cankaya C. Effect of fasting on contrast sensitivity in healthy males. J Ophthalmic Vis Res 2019;14:315-20.
Duru Z. The effect of voluntary fasting and dehydration on posterior ocular structures. Cutan Ocul Toxicol 2019;38:190-5.
Rimmani HH, Rustom LB, Rahal MA, Shayto RH, Chaar H, Sharara AI. Dexlansoprazole is effective in relieving heartburn during the fasting month of Ramadan. Dig Dis 2019;37:188-93.
Ebrahimi S, Gargari BP, Aliasghari F, Asjodi F, Izadi A. Ramadan fasting improves liver function and total cholesterol in patients with nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. Int J Vitam Nutr Res 2020;90:95-102.
Özkul C, Yalınay M, Karakan T. Islamic fasting leads to an increased abundance of Akkermansia muciniphila
and Bacteroides fragilis
group: A preliminary study on intermittent fasting. Turk J Gastroenterol 2019;30:1030-5.
Jarrar AH, Beasley JM, Ohuma EO, Ismail CL, Qeshta DA, Mohamad MN, et al
. Effect of high fiber cereal intake on satiety and gastrointestinal symptoms during Ramadan. Nutrients 2019;11:E939.
Ben Fraj S, Miladi A, Guezguez F, Ben Rejeb M, Bouguila J, Gargouri I, et al
. Does Ramadan fasting affect spirometric data of healthy adolescents? Clin Med Insights Pediatr 2019;13:1179556519862280.
Mohammad Y, Dubaybo B, Yusuf MO. How to manage asthma during Ramadan? Tunis Med 2019;97:1073-6.
Bragazzi NL, Sellami M, Salem I, Conic R, Kimak M, Pigatto PD, et al
. Fasting and its impact on skin anatomy, physiology, and physiopathology: A comprehensive review of the literature. Nutrients 2019;11:E247.
Damiani G, Mahroum N, Pigatto PD, Pacifico A, Malagoli P, Tiodorovic D, et al
. The safety and impact of a model of intermittent, time-restricted circadian fasting (“Ramadan Fasting”) on hidradenitis suppurativa: Insights from a multicenter, observational, cross-over, pilot, exploratory study. Nutrients 2019;11:E1781.
Damiani G, Watad A, Bridgewood C, Pigatto PD, Pacifico A, Malagoli P, et al
. The impact of Ramadan fasting on the reduction of PASI score, in moderate-to-severe psoriatic patients: A real-life multicenter study. Nutrients 2019;11:E277.
Setyopranoto RI, Hadi H, Wirohadidjojo YW. The effect of Ramadan fasting on sebum production: Association with nutritional intakes and sleeping pattern. Bangladesh J Med Sci 2019;18:546-51.
Adawi M, Damiani G, Bragazzi NL, Bridgewood C, Pacifico A, Conic RR, et al
. The impact of intermittent fasting (Ramadan fasting) on psoriatic arthritis disease activity, enthesitis, and dactylitis: A multicentre study. Nutrients 2019;11:E601.
Zghal Mghaieth F, Bonkano A, Boudiche S, Ayari J, Ben Mansour N, Rekik B, et al
. Oral anticoagulation therapy using acenocoumarol during the month of Ramadan: A comparative study between fasting and non-fasting patients. Tunis Med 2019;97:1177-86.
Ghiasian M, Mansour M, Moradian N. Prognosis of fasting in patients with cerebral venous thrombosis using oral contraceptives. Iran J Neurol 2019;18:82-4.
Dabbous Z, Alowainati B, Darwish S, Ali H, Farook S, Al Malaheem M, et al
. A prospective study comparing two-time points of thyroid hormone replacement during the holy month of Ramadan. Int J Endocrinol 2019;2019:9843961. doi: 10.1155/2019/9843961. PMID: 31428148; PMCID: PMC6681581.
Faris MA, Jahrami HA, Alsibai J, Obaideen AA. Impact of Ramadan diurnal intermittent fasting on metabolic syndrome components in healthy, non-athletic Muslim people aged over 15 years: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Nutr 2019:1-51. doi: 10.1017/S000711451900254X. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 31581955.
Beltaief K, Bouida W, Trabelsi I, Baccouche H, Sassi M, Dridi Z, et al.
Metabolic effects of Ramadan fasting in patients at high risk of cardiovascular diseases. Int J Gen Med 2019;12:247-54.
Faris MA, Madkour MI, Obaideen AK, Dalah EZ, Hasan HA, Radwan H, et al
. Effect of Ramadan diurnal fasting on visceral adiposity and serum adipokines in overweight and obese individuals. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 2019;153:166-75.
Madkour MI, El-Serafi AT, Jahrami HA, Sherif NM, Hassan RE, Awadallah S, et al
. Ramadan diurnal intermittent fasting modulates SOD2, TFAM, Nrf2, and sirtuins (SIRT1, SIRT3) gene expressions in subjects with overweight and obesity. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 2019;155:107801. doi: 10.1016/j.diabres.2019.107801. Epub 2019 Jul 26. PMID: 31356832.
Tabrizi N, Karimi N. Clinical epidemiologic study of admissions due to neurologic diseases during and after Ramadan fasting, Sari, Iran. J Mazandaran Univ Med Sci 2019;29:117-25.
Kamel WA, Al Hashel JY, Damier P. How do Parkinson's disease patients manage Ramadan fasting? An observational study. Rev Neurol 2019;175:560-3.
Laatar R, Baccouch R, Borji R, Kachouri H, Rebai H, Sahli S. Ramadan fasting effects on postural control in the elderly: A comparison between fallers and non-fallers. J Relig Health 2019;58:28-40.
Düzçeker Y, Akgül S, Durmaz Y, Yaman M, Örs S, Tüzün Z, et al
. Is Ramadan fasting correlated with disordered eating behaviours in adolescents? Eat Disord 2019;13:1-14.
Briki W, Aloui A, Bragazzi NL, Chamari K. The buffering effect of Ramadan fasting on emotions intensity: A pilot study. Tunis Med 2019;97:1187-91.
Pourabbasi A, Ebrahimnegad Shirvani MS, Shams AH. Does Islamic fasting affect cognitive functions in adolescents? A systematic review. J Pak Med Assoc 2019;69:1164-9.
Boukhris O, Trabelsi K, Shephard RJ, Hsouna H, Abdessalem R, Chtourou L, et al
. Sleep patterns, alertness, dietary intake, muscle soreness, fatigue, and mental stress recorded before, during and after Ramadan observance. Sports (Basel) 2019;7:E118.
Almeneessier AS, BaHammam AA, Olaish AH, Pandi-Perumal SR, Manzar MD, BaHammam AS. Effects of diurnal intermittent fasting on daytime sleepiness reflected by EEG absolute power. J Clin Neurophysiol 2019;36:213-9.
Faris MA, Jahrami HA, Alhayki FA, Alkhawaja NA, Ali AM, Aljeeb SH, et al
. Effect of diurnal fasting on sleep during Ramadan: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Sleep Breath 2019;24:771-82.
Trabelsi K, Ammar A, Zlitni S, Boukhris O, Khacharem A, El-Abed K, et al
. Practical recommendations to improve sleep during Ramadan observance in healthy practitioners of physical activity. Tunis Med 2019;97:1077-86.
Amin ME, Abdelmageed A. Clinicians' perspectives on caring for Muslim patients considering fasting during Ramadan. J Relig Health 2019;59:1370-87.
Amin ME, Abdelmageed A, Farhat MJ. Communicating with clinicians on fasting during Ramadan: The patients' perspective. J Relig Health. 2019. doi: 10.1007/s10943-019-00910-x. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 31485879.
Ben Saida IB, Kallel H, Chaouch S, Toumi R, Zarrougui W, Boussarsar M. Impacts of Ramadan on intensive care unit admission patterns and outcomes. Tunis Med 2019;97:1153-9.
Riccò M, Garbarino S, Bragazzi NL. Migrant workers from the eastern-Mediterranean region and occupational injuries: A retrospective database-based analysis from North-Eastern Italy. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2019;16:E673.
Kankou J, Bouchaud O, Lele N, Guiguet M, Spire B, Carrieri MP, et al.
Factors associated with virological rebound in HIV-positive Sub-Saharan Migrants living in France after traveling back to their native country: ANRS-VIHVO 2006–2009 study. J Immigr Minor Health 2019;21:1342-8.
Haq H, Khan RA, Yasmin R. Healthcare needs of the Muslim patient community in the undergraduate medical curriculum-Are they there? Pak J Med Sci 2019;35:836-41.